America’s two most capable mid-size trucks, redesigned and ready for duty. We compare specs, price, performance, and real-world capability to help you choose the right truck.
in Illinois
Since 1988
Try Before You Buy
Service Center
Here’s how these two redesigned mid-size trucks stack up across the categories that matter most to truck buyers.
Colorado wins on base-level price — the regular-cab Colorado starts at $30,500 versus the Tacoma’s $32,000 for an Access Cab. However, the Tacoma’s higher starting point reflects more standard features and the option for a hybrid powertrain, which is unprecedented in the mid-size segment.
The Tacoma’s hybrid option carries a modest premium — roughly $2,500–$3,000 over the gas model — but delivers better fuel economy and superior resale value over the vehicle’s life.
Lower base price ($30,500 vs $32,000). More bed length options (up to 6.0 ft). Available Super Cruise semi-autonomous driving.
Hybrid delivers better fuel economy (23–29 MPG). Stronger long-term resale value. Lower total cost of ownership over time.
On raw towing numbers, the Colorado edges ahead at 7,700 lbs versus the Tacoma’s 6,800 lbs. However, the Tacoma’s payload capacity (1,840 lbs) beats the Colorado (1,680 lbs), making it better for heavy bedload work.
The Tacoma’s hybrid model adds 326 hp and exceptional torque delivery through the e-CVT — useful for tight terrain navigation and mountain passes.
Higher towing capacity (7,700 vs 6,800 lbs) for trailer and boat owners. Larger infotainment screen.
Higher payload (1,840 vs 1,680 lbs). Hybrid torque (465 lb-ft) superior for off-road. TRD Pro tri-link rear suspension refined over years of real-world testing.
Winner: Toyota Tacoma. The Tacoma’s TRD Pro and Trailhunter models offer proven, purpose-built off-road engineering with Multi-Mode AWD and decades of TRD platform refinement.
Winner: Chevy Colorado. If you regularly pull a 7,000+ lb travel trailer or boat, the Colorado’s 7,700 lb towing capacity and available 6-foot bed offer more capacity.
Winner: Toyota Tacoma (with hybrid). The Tacoma’s hybrid model delivers the best fuel economy (23–29 MPG) and quietest ride with Toyota Safety Sense 2.5 standard across all trims.
Winner: Toyota Tacoma. Tacomas retain 55–60% of original value after five years vs Colorado’s 50–55%. Toyota’s reliability reputation and strong buyer demand make the Tacoma the smarter long-term investment.
The Colorado wins on base price and towing capacity. But the Tacoma wins on reliability, resale value, hybrid efficiency, and off-road credibility. If you’re buying a truck you plan to keep for 10+ years, the Tacoma’s legendary reliability and strong long-term value make it the smarter choice.
Our recommendation: Drive both on our test track. The best truck is the one that fits your lifestyle — schedule a test drive at Toyota of Naperville today.
Both are excellent trucks. The Tacoma is better for off-roading, fuel economy (hybrid), and resale value. The Colorado is better for towing capacity and base-level pricing. Your choice depends on your primary use.
The 2026 Tacoma can tow 6,800 lbs when properly equipped. The Colorado’s 7,700 lb capacity is higher for large travel trailers or commercial applications.
No, the 2026 Colorado does not offer a hybrid powertrain. The Tacoma is the only mid-size truck with a standard hybrid option, making it the leader in fuel economy for the segment.
The Tacoma retains 55–60% of its original value after five years versus Colorado’s 50–55%. Toyota’s reliability reputation and strong buyer demand support better long-term value.
The 2026 Toyota Tacoma starts at $32,000 for the base Access Cab with the 2.4L turbo gas engine. Visit Toyota of Naperville to review current pricing and available incentives.
Yes! Toyota of Naperville has Tacomas in stock and our on-site test track lets you experience real-world driving. Schedule a test drive today at (630) 524-4216.
